The Sixth Annual Winter Course on Forced Migration, 2008

2.  

 Structure of the Course 
                   

On 15 December 2008 the Sixth Annual Winter Course on Forced Migration came to an end. The course since its inception has tried to move beyond the issues of forced migration and incorporated various salient features about the reasons of migration and displacement. Despite its South Asian focus, an attempt is made to draw a comparative analysis from other regions to discuss issues of forced migration, racism and xenophobia. The major emphasis of the Sixth Annual Winter course on Forced Migration was to address the impact of climate change and its impact on population movement. The Course has attempted to constantly reinvent itself keeping with the time and issues like climate change and its impact on forced displacement, media coverage of refugee experiences and displacement issues were some of the highlights of this year’s programme. In addition to this, the legal regimes of protection and ethics of care and justice is particularly important to understand the recent tightening of borders due to “security “ reasons. This only reproduces vulnerability of the migrants and creates hierarchies. The course builds on CRG’s ongoing research work on displacement and forced migration has attempted to question these power structures and hierarchies. It plays particular attention to various forms of vulnerabilities in displacement without creating any hierarchies. Hence it is constantly evolving.  

With the increasing importance to study the impact of climate change the course committee introduced a compulsory module on “Resource politics, climate change, environmental degradation, and displacement”. The course is built around eight modules. 

The Compulsory modules 

A. States, Partitions, and Issues of Citizenship

B. Gender dimensions of forced migration, vulnerabilities, and justice

C. International, regional, and the national legal regimes of protection, sovereignty and the principle of responsibility

D. Internal displacement with special reference to causes, linkages, and responses

E. Resource politics, climate change, environmental degradation, and displacement 

The Optional modules  

F. Research methodology in Forced Migration Studies

G. Ethics of care and protection

H. Media and displacement and forced migration  

The course activities besides the writings assignments, included workshops assignments, media assignments, group discussions, field visit, creative sessions of film screenings and a day long media workshop and face to face interactions with resource persons experienced in related areas.  

Duration and activities 

The course is divided into two segments. The distance education segment course began on 1 September during which core reading material with short introductory notes were sent to each participants. The reading materials were sent to the participants in three phases.  For review assignments and term papers, lead questions and discussion points were sent at regular intervals. Each module had a tutor and a number of faculty members. On the basis of the modules chosen by them the participants were encouraged to contact the faculty persons for necessary advice and inputs. Chat sessions were organised so that participants could discuss their assignments with module tutors. 

Participants were required to prepare an assignment paper each and bring the papers with them for the workshops where the papers were discussed. These papers were first read and commented upon by the module tutors and then made available for wider circulation and discussion in the CRG website. The participants were also given assignments termed as creative assignment so that the period of three months could also be used for training in communication aspects of humanitarian and human rights work, and other practical aspects such as providing the participants with information and documentation skills, preparing local data base, campaign for fund-raising for human rights and humanitarian efforts, and report writing. Creative assignments were made a mandatory part of the course since 2006 and their results were varied and rich. Participation in the field visit to Hamidpur Char, Malda was also compulsory. 

The preparation of course material was of great significance. The course material included mandatory, optional and supplementary materials. The mandatory materials included a number of books, essays and web-based materials. Supplementary materials including one CRG publication on erosion-affected people of Malda for fieldwork were handed to them when they arrived in Kolkata. Three weeks before the participants arrived in Kolkata they were given workshop themes. Each of them was required to participate in one of the workshops. Participants were graded on all these assignments and on the valedictory day these grades were handed to them.   

Since 2005, the course has introduced two optional modules. In 2008, one compulsory module on ‘Resource politics, climate change, environmental degradation, and displacement ’ was introduced as per the recommendations of the Advisory Committee Meeting of the Sixth CRG Winter Course on Forced Migration held on 5-6 April 2008 in Darjeeling. The module on “Research Methodology in Forced Migration Studies” was introduced as an optional module. This year the participants, besides completing three compulsory assignments (term paper assignment, review assignment and creative assignment) had the option of engaging with another optional assignment based on the module “Media and displacement and forced migration”.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

From Left to Right: Montserrat Feixas Vihe and Sanna Selin

 

Participants

Twenty participants were selected for the course, of whom sixteen could complete the course. These participants were selected through public notifications and were drawn from backgrounds of law, social and humanitarian work, human rights work, and academic and research work. Most of them came from South Asia but a few were also from other regions such as Argentina, Italy and Canada and brought forth with them wider experiences of refugee-hood and of rehabilitation and care.  Those who could not complete the course were unable to do so mainly due to sudden indisposition and visa problems. 

Faculty 

The faculty was drawn from people with recognized backgrounds in refugee studies, studies in internal displacement, university teaching and research, humanitarian work in NGOs, legal studies, UN functionaries, particularly UNHCR functionaries; public policy analysis, journalism, and concerned human rights activism and humanitarian work. Attention was paid to diversity of background and region. Importance was attached to the requirements of the syllabus; the faculty was also involved in developing on a permanent scale a syllabus, a set of reading materials, evaluation, and follow-up activities. They graded participants on their skills such as speaking and writing skills, analysis of themes chosen, execution of creative assignments etc.  

Evaluation 

The participants were evaluated by a number of resource persons.  The core faculty evaluated each of their assignments. All the resource persons present evaluated their presentations, including the presentation of their term papers.  They were given a grade for the distance education segment and another for the Kolkata workshop.  At the end of the course they were given a cumulative grade. The course is equivalent to six credit hours of graduate level work. 

The course has a built in evaluation system. Each participant is required to present a written evaluation and each resource person is also expected to do the same. Every year CRG invites independent scholars of renown, social activists and administrators to evaluate the course.  This year Subrata Kumar Hore, Faculty, Bidhannaore Government College, (West Bengal State University) evaluated the course.  Excerpts from his evaluation report are presented in Section 14. 

Follow-Up 

CRG has organized follow up programmes in collaboration with various universities in the past. This year one such course was held from 26-28 February 2008 in Chennai. A few others are in the pipeline and discussions are being held with some university departments and law schools for holding short-duration courses.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Participants in a session in Swabhumi